Skip to main content
The Ultimate Senior Resource

Senior Living in Bay Shore, NY

3 Communities

Bay Shore, NY: Ultimate Senior Resource lists 3 senior living communities, including 2 assisted living, 2 memory care and 1 independent living communities (as of ).

3
Operators
12.72%
Seniors (65+) vs 17.3% national

See Bay Shore senior living costs →

3 Senior Living Communities in Bay Shore

3 communities

Assisted Living in Bay Shore, NY

2 assisted living communities in Bay Shore, NY are listed on Ultimate Senior Resource.

Atria Bay Shore - Senior Living in Bay Shore, New York

Atria Bay Shore

53 Ocean Avenue

Assisted LivingIndependent LivingMemory Care
Netherbay at Bay Shore - Senior Living in Bay Shore, New York

Netherbay at Bay Shore

36 South Clinton Avenue

Assisted LivingMemory CareRespite Care

Memory Care in Bay Shore, NY

2 memory care communities in Bay Shore, NY are listed on Ultimate Senior Resource.

Atria Bay Shore

53 Ocean Avenue

Also offers assisted living and independent living

Netherbay at Bay Shore

36 South Clinton Avenue

Also offers assisted living

Independent Living in Bay Shore, NY

1 independent living community in Bay Shore, NY is listed on Ultimate Senior Resource.

Atria Bay Shore

53 Ocean Avenue

Also offers assisted living and memory care

Skilled Nursing in Bay Shore, NY

1 skilled nursing facility in Bay Shore, NY is listed on Ultimate Senior Resource.

Who Operates Senior Living in Bay Shore

3 operators run all of Bay Shore's 3 senior living communities listed on Ultimate Senior Resource.

Atria Senior Living (1)

Assisted LivingIndependent LivingMemory Care

For profit - Corporation (1)

Meridian Senior Living (1)

Assisted LivingMemory CareRespite Care

Bay Shore, located on the South Shore of Long Island, offers seniors a unique blend of waterfront charm and suburban convenience. This historic village provides access to the Great South Bay, ferry service to Fire Island, and a vibrant downtown area along Main Street. With 2 senior living communities serving the area, families have options for assisted living and specialized care in a location that balances small-town character with proximity to New York City's world-class healthcare resources.

The community's location in Suffolk County provides seniors with access to excellent medical facilities, including nearby Southside Hospital and Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center. Bay Shore's downtown district offers walkable streets with restaurants, shops, and cultural venues like the Boulton Center for the Performing Arts. The village's rich maritime heritage and active waterfront create opportunities for scenic enjoyment, while the LIRR station provides convenient transportation for family visits. For families considering senior living options, Bay Shore presents a balanced environment where quality care meets community engagement in a classic Long Island setting.

Cost of Senior Living in Bay Shore

These elevated costs reflect the area's overall cost of living and the quality of care provided on Long Island. Families should note that actual expenses vary based on the level of care required, room type, and specific amenities offered by each community. Many communities offer different pricing tiers based on individual care needs and apartment sizes.

Assisted living
$7,110
per month, New York median (15% above U.S.)
Nursing home, semi-private room
$15,528
per month, New York median (62% above U.S.)
Non-medical caregiver (in-home care)
$6,673
per month, New York median (same as U.S.)

Source: CareScout Cost of Care Survey, 2025 (state median). These are statewide medians; no Bay Shore-specific survey figure is published. Each community quotes its own rates.

Choosing Between Care Types in Bay Shore

Families can find communities providing medication management, personal care assistance, dining services, and social programming. The proximity to Long Island's healthcare infrastructure ensures residents have access to additional medical services and specialists when needed.

Frequently Asked Questions About Senior Living in Bay Shore

What is the average cost of senior living in Bay Shore, NY?
The median cost of assisted living in New York was $7,110 a month in the 2025 survey, 15% above the national median of $6,200. A semi-private nursing home room was $15,528 a month. Source: CareScout Cost of Care Survey, 2025 (state median). These are statewide medians; no Bay Shore-specific survey figure is published, so ask each community for its current rates.

Find Senior Living in Bay Shore, NY

Need help choosing the right community? Contact us for personalized guidance.

Get Help Today